Information, Ideas, and Insight into Adult ADD and related issues with the occasional inclusion of other insundry, unrelated rantings.
Are you drinking the wrong soda?
Published on June 21, 2004 By mrperky In Health & Medicine
I just bought one of the new C2 Coke's at the local Target in the nifty 8-pack. Further, the vending machine upstairs now carries C2 as well as "straight" Coke. Nutritionally, C2 seems to have it going on. Calories fall from 140 to 70, total carbs from 39g to 18g, sugar from 39g to 18g (guess where the carbs come from...), and sodium from 50mg to 45mg. My informal taste test shows that it tastes _exactly_ the same, with no sweetener aftertaste. So, it looks like a home run for Coke, right?

Unfortunately, there is one nagging question in my mind. And it's a big question, clamoring for attention, gesticulating wildly with a cigarette stained hand. If Coke can offer the same product with such a nutritional advantage over the "straight" Coke, then why hasn't it already? We should have had this Coke years ago. Indeed, this should have been the New Coke, and then we would have had a reason to switch!

So, why is Coke still feeding us the inferior "straight" Coke? If Coke can make the new C2 with 70 calories, can it make do with only 35? I have lost faith in Coke's earnestness and sense of propriety. Further, because I view all soda companies similarly, why isn't Pepsii making a low-carlorie (not a 0 or 1 calorie, mind you) soda? Could there be a 35 calorie Cheerwine coming soon to a soda fountain near you?

Comments (Page 2)
2 Pages1 2 
on Jun 23, 2004
Kayles - I think the aspartame is truly unneccesary in C2. The Pepsi product "Pepsi Edge" does not have aspartame listed as an ingredient, although the product is not out yet and may have the ingredients changed. Sucralose is sugar derived and seems to be harmless. From the International Food Information Council Q & A about Sucralose:

Is sucralose safe?

Yes. More than 100 scientific studies over a 20 year period have demonstrated the safety of sucralose. Importantly, comprehensive toxicology studies, designed to meet the highest scientific standards, have clearly demonstrated that sucralose is not carcinogenic. The data from the studies were independently evaluated by international experts in a variety of scientific disciplines, including toxicology, oncology, teratology, neurology, hematology, pediatrics and nutrition. What regulatory bodies reviewed the safety profile of sucralose? In addition to the FDA, the safety of sucralose has been confirmed by the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA); the Health Protection Branch of Health and Welfare Canada; the National Food Authority of Australia; and the health ministries of Argentina, Brazil, China, and Mexico, for a total of more than 30 countries throughout the world.

dharmagrl - I really can't taste the difference. Maybe my taste buds are fried from my long career as a fire eater? If water were 25 cents and available in most/every vending machine, I'd drink it over softdrinks almost always. However, since the vendimg machine is my friend, it's diet pepsi and now, maybe, C2.
on Jun 23, 2004
I ran into a gas station last night to buy my wife a soda. I was in such a rush, I didn't realize that I had picked up a C2 by accident(it looks JUST like regular coke). My wife noticed, but we tried it anyway. She noticed a small difference in taste, and didn't like the difference. I noticed a big difference, and also didn't like it. It tasted almost like a diet soda to me. We did all this taste testing before we had ANY idea what C2 was all about. Then she read that it half the sugar etc.. and that explained to my why it tasted "diety".

on Jul 15, 2004
I've tried the new CocaCola C2 and wonder why it hasn't been put on the market long before. I've always thought all soda was too sweet, this is just right. I hope it stays and other companies will follow suit.
on Jul 15, 2004
I finally tried it and thought it was bland.
on Jul 15, 2004
I have quite a bit of it here and I like it..."okay". But I still prefer the full stuff better.  It does taste diety but not nearly as diety as the actual diet drinks which I can't tolerate at all.
on Jul 16, 2004
I think it's a good middle ground.  You can't expect something that has 1/2 the calories to taste exactly like the full sugar stuff.   Once you drink only it for awhile you pretty much forget what the full calorie stuff tastes like.  I only drink one or two sodas a week, sometimes I don't drink any, but C2 is a pretty good option for me since I can't have too many simple sugars.  (Need to save the sugar for the coffee )
on Jul 16, 2004
gesticulating wildly with a cigarette stained hand.


Don't worry about the nutritional values of coke. The cigarette's gonna kill ya anyway!
on Jan 05, 2005
your coke is the best i love it
on Jan 05, 2005

Be VERY, very careful when it comes to aspartame. Many individuals have bad reactions to it. Better to drink water or beer


mmmm, beeer....

2 Pages1 2